09, 2024
We put the most popular frozen pies to the test.
Find out which brand is the one you should keep in your freezer for last-minute guests.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature.
We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
Picture it: Youve got unexpected company over.
What do you do?
If youre me, you keep a just-in-case dessert in the freezer for this exact scenario.
Do you chooseEdwards,Marie CallendersorSara Lee?
They all look tasty and chocolaty on the box, but is one better than the next?
Our team put these three brands to the test.
This pie was very smooth and creamy with an almost buttery taste.
$6.39; available nationwide.
That wasnt a bad thing, though!
On the flip side, the pie did take longer to defrost.
The chocolate was satisfying and lushbut pretty rich so a thin slice is all youd need.
$7.99; available nationwide.
This frozen pie is like a grown-updirt cake.
The chocolate filling was light and creamy.
Topped with chocolate shards, it had a bit of crunchy texture that we just adored.
Our favorite part, though, was the cookie crumb crust.
Who doesnt love Oreo-style cookie crumbs?
Layered up with the topping and filling, it made this dessert worthy of a second slice.
Prices vary; available nationwide.
Each was creamy, chocolaty and sweet.
No substitute forhomemade chocolate cream pietopped withreal whipped creamof course, but still satisfying.
But, if you pressed me on it, Id recommend snagging a Sara Lee pie.
No one can resist a cookie crust and chocolate shards.
Its the most people-pleasing of the bunch.
All opinions shared are our own and have not been influenced by advertisers.
We recommend our users to update the web app.
