Is there a consensus on whether its better to store peanut butter in the fridge or the pantry?

Simply Recipes / Getty Images

After years of restaurant experience, I know my way around a kitchen.

When kept in the fridge, your peanut butter will be firmer.

skippy peanut butter jars

Simply Recipes / Getty Images

Or, a PB and honey if youre me.

Hovick says, They are both formulated and processed in a manner that helps to contain oil separation.

Is It Safe To Store Peanut Butter at Room Temperature?

spoonful of peanut butter lifted from a jar

Simply Recipes / Getty Images

No-stir peanut butter lasts longer than “natural” options because it contains stabilizers that increase its shelf life.

peanut butter cookies (some on a plate and some on the counter) next to a jar of peanut butter

Simply Recipes / Getty Images