We tested 14 toasters to find the best options for home cooks.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature.
We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
In our opinion, the best toaster saves space, browns evenly and rings up at a good value.
But not all toasters are created equal.
This toaster offers the same sleek look as the linescookware set, a bonus in our book.
Even better, the matte finish doesnt show fingerprints after regular use.
It also arrived with zero dents or dings thanks to its robust, recyclable packaging.
When unplugged, the controls disappear for a pleasant neutral display.
The lever also offers a lift function to help remove squat breads like English muffins.
Interestingly, the manual said not to toast pastries with runny fillings or icing.
We went ahead anyway for science, using the lowest setting.
It turned out fine, so in our opinion its certainly possible to still enjoy pastries with this toaster.
On the lightest toast setting, this was one of the quickest toasters to finish.
It adds a substantial crisp on both sides of the bread without any browning.
The medium setting offers a nice all-over browning that even reaches the edges.
What more could you ask for in a mid-price toaster?
However, we can assure you that theCafe Express toasteris truly as beautiful as it is effective.
An eye-catching brushed stainless finish with copper accents on the knobs and feet look put-together.
Shoppers enjoy a choice of three shades: black matte, white matte and stainless steel.
Those that prefer light toast may be disappointed with the uneven browning and varying intensity on the lowest setting.
Sure, the unit is basic and has its drawbacks.
Theres also no frozen/defrost setting.
It offers passable performance for toaster pastries, too.
Theres no designated setting, so we just used low heat.
The center came out warm and the edges of the pastry did get brown.
Its also more stable than expected from a budget pick.
Those expecting an inexpensive toaster that performs as expected will find the Proctor Silex toaster a suitable option.
We chose the Empire Red model with reflective red plastic sides and a brushed stainless top band.
Chrome vents on the side give it a retro automobile feel that we love.
That said, this is definitely one of the best toasters for those who prefer light to medium-dark toast.
Most importantly, though, is that the KitchenAid toaster performs well across the board.
In our tests involving waffles and a toaster pastry on low, it performed nicely.
This guy is slow and steadythough he did win some of the races.
Enjoying a freshly toasted piece of sourdough that was made withstyle.
The distinctive retro style is a definite eye-catcher.
It also comes in a whopping total of 11 different colors, sizes and finishes.
Since its made from alloy steel, its surprisingly resistant to dents and dings.
The feet are a rubbery silicone that prevent slips and slides.
In terms of pastry performance, it gave us a thoroughly warmed pastry with an ooey, gooey center.
The lowest toast setting offered zero browning, but theres a definitely crisp to the exterior of the bread.
Its about as light as you could possibly go while still constituting as toast.
Medium gave us an impressively even brown on all sides, but was overall pretty dark for mid-level toast.
We consider this ones performance on-par with the lower priced toasters on our list.
You wont find a gimmicky LED screen or touch controls here.
Instead, its whatsinsidethat takes this toaster to the next level.
In terms of toast, the lowest setting offers a really nice kiss of brown all over.
Each piece was pleasantly crispy.
That may be a pro for some who prefer dark brown toast to blackened pieces.
This is one of only two toasters that could fit the 7.25-in.
squat sourdough bread (at an angle).
Remarkably, the Breville also hides fingerprints very well.
Youd think no one has ever touched it!
A button labeled A Bit More does exactly that, adding a bit more time to the toasting clock.
Both buttons are a nice touch, and two of the features that makes this option a standout.
But for an Amazon Basic item, this toaster feels more substantial than others.
Its classy, slip-resistant and durable.
The lowest toaster setting offered no browning, but the bread was nicely crispy.
Despite that, it was really quite even compared to the other options we tested.
Only one side of each bagel half was browned up, so the performance wasnt very even.
But this was still more successful than some of the competitors.
Sure, you’ve got the option to always fire up your trustedtoaster oven.
Theyre often cheaper, too.
To narrow things down, think of what aspects are the most important to your family.
Are you looking for a toaster that offers a touchscreen and artisanal toasting modes?
Next, consider your budget.
This step is easier once you determine your needs.
Larger four-slice toasters are often pricier than their two-slice counterparts, but price also depends on functionality.
Generally, those looking for a simple appliance without extra bells and whistles can safely spend under $100.
We know that toasters may not be the most glamorous kitchen appliance.
However, we firmly believe that everyone deserves a reliable option that delivers a delicious crunch.
Breakfast should always be free from burn marks and uneven browning.
Many of us have backgrounds in kitchen and culinary careers ourselves.
From there, we spent three days testing 14 different toaster options in our Testing Lab.
Our picks ranged from $23.99 all the way up to $297.
We recommend our users to update the net web client.
