The more expensive one isn’t always the best.

It’s confusing even for someone who works in food like me!

Here’s what I learned.

Different bottles of olive oil

Simply Recipes / Getty Images

What Is Extra Virgin Olive Oil?

That said, some good-quality extra virgin olive oils are pale yellow.

What Is Regular Olive Oil (aka Refined Olive Oil)?

Olive oil poured into a bowl

Simply Recipes / Andrew Christensen

Refined olive oil tends to be more affordable and has a longer shelf life than extra virgin olive oil.

Profaci adds that about 75% of olive oils sold are virgini.e., extra virginand 25% are refined.

Simply Recipes / Andrew Christensen

When Is It Best To Use Extra Virgin vs. Roszkowski says extra virgin olive oil is great for when you want a strong olive taste.

slice top off of garlic head, pour over with olive oil

Simply Recipes

Both experts agree that in many cases it comes down to personal preference or what you have on hand.

It’s a great choice when you want a milder flavor or are cooking at very high temperatures.