This recipe for the New England classic keeps it simple and lets the lobster shine.

Maybe its the longing for it that makes it so.

One thing is required when it comes to sunny summer days: the lobster roll.

Plate of the best lobster roll recipe served with a side of chips and a lemon wedge.

Sally Vargas

Thats the essence of summer here, with or without the dock.

Proust can have his madeleines.

I will take a lobster roll.

How to make lobster rolls with individual bowls of the lobster salad ingredients set on a table.

Sally Vargas

There is something so comforting about eating a lobster roll on a hot dog bun.

It says, “Nothin fancy here, folks.”

Yes, New Englanders have attitude aplenty, too.

Article image

Sally Vargas

But its a cheaters affair.

We rarely start with a live lobster.

I mean, you could.

Lobster roll on a plate with potato chips and lemon wedges

Sally Vargas

You could also start a sandwich by baking bread from scratch.

Whats the Best Lobster for Lobster Rolls?

If you are reading this from Minnesota, I apologize.

Glass mixing bowl with chopped lobster, mayo and diced celery to make a homemade lobster roll recipe.

Sally Vargas

Freshly cooked New England lobster meat purchased locally really is the best.

For cooked frozen meat, just thaw in the refrigerator before using.

The time will depend on how large the tail.

Mixing bowl with creamy lobster salad to make a homemade lobster roll recipe.

Sally Vargas

A 3- to 6-ounce tail will take about 4 to 6 minutes.

Some lobster rolls are made with just lobster, a little lemon juice, and salt and pepper.

Now thats true understatement.

Three split rolls buttered and in a skillet to toast for a homemade lobster roll recipe.

Sally Vargas

What Is a New England Style Hot Dog Bun?

Those sides can be buttered and grilled in a pan.

Taste and add more salt, pepper, or lemon juice, if you like.

How to make lobster rolls by toasting the bun. Three split buns, toasted and on a plate.

Sally Vargas

Spread the outsides of the buns with softened butter.

Set a skillet or cast iron pan over medium-high heat.

Toast the buns for about 30 seconds on each side, or until golden brown.

Fill each bun with lobster salad.

Serve with potato chips and a wedge of lemon.

Did you love the recipe?

Let us know with a rating and review!